Front End Loading (FEL-1): How Owners Can Make Informed Decisions Before Investing in Capital Projects
The earliest decisions made during a capital project drive the entire direction of the project and have the greatest impact on the success of the project, from schedule and budget to scope and operability. FEL-1 is the first phase of the Front End Loading approach which gives owners the opportunity to determine whether a project is worth pursuing, and more importantly, whether they are pursuing the right project.
It has unfortunately become common for many organizations to think of FEL-1 as the first step in project development and cost estimating. Instead, FEL-1 should be treated as the first decision-making phase. The depth and quality of questions asked in this phase drives the choices and direction of the rest of the project.
1. Make Sure You’re Solving the Right Problem
It’s easy to jump to solutions before fully understanding the business need. A new building, equipment replacement, or plant expansion may seem like the obvious answer, but is it addressing the real issue? In addition, each stakeholder brings a unique perspective, someone with an operations background may be more focused on ease of operability and automation while someone with a maintenance background may be more concerned with equipment access and routine upkeep. Clearly defining the problem helps ensure the project remains focused on business outcomes instead of (sometimes contradictory) predetermined solutions.
An experienced engineering contractor can help parse out the various stakeholder requirements, facilitate discussions which lead to good questions, and offer alternatives to a proposed solution. Some questions to discuss in this FEL-1 phase are:
- What business problem are we trying to solve? Is this a capacity issue, reliability issue, operational bottleneck, or is the project driven by safety and environmental risks?
- What happens if we do nothing? What potential risks would we be accepting if nothing is done?
- What nice-to-have requests do various stakeholders have which may or may not be strictly required for the project?
2. Define What Success Looks Like
Since every stakeholder is likely to have a different vision of project success, it is important to align on measurable project goals. Establishing success criteria early can help identify project requirements vs nice-to-have additions in future phases of the project.
An engineering contractor with a field-focus will approach engineering design through the lens of constructability, operability, and maintenance requirements, as well as lead conversations about project scope requirements and desired additions.
Defining project success criteria determines the project scope, and early delineation of scope ensures that the project direction and cost estimates stay on track.
3. Challenge Assumptions Before They Become Expensive
Every project begins with assumptions. When design basis is established and possible solutions are evaluated, the entire project rests on those initial assumptions. If future engineering phases discover that the original assumptions were not correct, costly scope additions and rework may become necessary. Therefore, all assumptions should be questioned early and verified or recorded as potential project risks.
An engineering contractor can help ask the right questions to identify which assumptions are reasonable and which could become a hidden risk. Previous project experience often highlights the assumptions about existing systems which later needed correction.
Some of these assumptions can be:
- Availability and status of utilities
- Adequacy of structural supports
- Expected production growth or production flexibility requirements
- Condition of existing equipment and systems
- Construction access
- Permitting and regulatory requirements
- Staffing and operations capabilities
Successful projects aren’t the ones without risk, but those where risks are identified early enough to be adequately managed.
4. Evaluate Multiple Options
The most common mistake in FEL-1 is becoming committed to a single solution too early. The FEL-1 phase is intended to compare alternatives and select the best option to proceed. Having exposure to various projects across multiple industries, a good engineering contractor can discuss other approaches which may not be typical for the owner but could offer a simpler or more cost effective solution. An engineering contractor can, therefore, be a valuable partner in proposing alternative solutions.
5. Be Willing to Say “Not Yet”
One potential outcome of FEL-1 is deciding that a project isn’t ready or shouldn’t move forward at all. If the potential solution is too expensive to implement and does not return the necessary improvement, the project may not be worth pursuing. Alternatively, FEL-1 efforts may highlight that only part of the original project should continue into next phases. The high level cost estimate and option selection of FEL-1 helps make informed investment decisions, even when the best decision might be delaying or redefining the project. An engineering contractor can put together high level cost estimates for a few possible options to enable the owner to make the decisions on which option, or sub-option, is worth selecting for the next FEL-2 phase.
The Value of a Strong FEL-1 Process
By the end of FEL-1, owners should have confidence that they understand the business need, have explored multiple options, recognized the project’s biggest risks, and have enough information to decide whether additional investment is justified to allow the project to proceed. Organizations that treat FEL-1 as a strategic decision-making stage gate are better positioned to avoid costly surprises, allocate capital spending more effectively, and proceed with projects that deliver lasting business value.
The best projects don’t begin with engineering drawings; they begin when the right questions are asked.
Read more in the series:
- FEL-2: How the Right Engineering Partner Can Reduce Project Risk (coming soon)
- FEL-3: How To Ensure The Project Is Ready For Funding And Execution (coming soon)